Perpetual Stock or Broth

This post may contain affiliate links. Thank you for supporting GNOWFGLINS with your purchases.

Last week we talked about how nourishing stock or broth is the foundation of a traditional diet and should be consumed regularly. Why? In addition to being rich with minerals, broth contains gelatin which aids digestion and helps the body more fully use protein. People on the GAPS diet are urged to eat a cup of broth a day.

That’s a little bit hard to do. For one thing, it is hard to find interesting and appetizing ways to get it in without drinking it straight. Don’t worry about that, though — Mindy and I and lots of commenters help you overcome that hurdle in last week’s post: 8 Ways To Get That Stock In (Without Drinking It Straight).

But what about keeping up the routine of making stock constantly, so it is always available? You know how that goes. Fill the pot with bones and water and vinegar. Simmer, strain, store, use. Wash the pot and start all over again. Practically daily. Yeah, that can be inconvenient. Worth it, definitely. But it could be simpler. It could be easier.

Let me introduce you to perpetual stock.

With perpetual stock, you hardly feel like you’re working at all. With perpetual stock, the stockpot is always on, always ready. You don’t have to store the stock, you don’t have to wash the pot daily, you’re not always messing with it. Here’s how.

Perpetual Stock or Broth

Here’s what you need — basically, it’s what you always need for stock, plus the crockpot.

  • bones and other animal parts
  • splash of apple cider vinegar
  • anything else you’d like to add, like onions, garlic, odds and ends of vegetables
  • good water
  • sea salt (optional)
  • crockpot — preferably at least 4 quart size

Put your bones and other food goodies in the crockpot and cover with water. Turn on to high for an hour, then turn down to low. Every crockpot is different, so adjust heat as necessary while the stock cooks. A gentle simmer is okay, but try to avoid a rolling boil. No simmer but consistent heat is good, too.

After half a day or so, you can begin ladling out stock as needed. I love having a crock of stock ready to add to every meal! Season it up in the dish you’re making or by the mug. Replace water as necessary and keep the stock going…

After a few days (or more often depending on how much broth you’ve used), scoop out the spent foodstuffs — they go to the compost. Usually I do this when the broth is no longer flavorful and no longer fatty.

Start the process over again by adding more bones and the other ingredients. Keep adding water and keep that broth going… and going…

A Few Notes

Every week or so, you should probably allow the stock to get very low in the crockpot without replacing water. Turn off the crock, then clean it. Then start all over again.

Last time I mentioned this (on a webinar, I think) someone mentioned that it might be good to switch crockpots so the one is not working all the time for weeks at a time. I think that’s a very good idea.

The most nourishing stock/broth comes from the most nourishing bones. Grass-fed, pastured, etc.

If your stock does not gel, consider adding good-quality gelatin.

GAPS people with very sensitive digestive systems may find long-simmered stock too rich. If this is you, don’t let the stock keep going for hours and hours or days.

Do you keep perpetual stock going? Any tips to share? Do you think this would help you get more broth in your diet? What do you think?

New to our GAPS series? Get up to speed by browsing past posts in this series or reading what the GAPS diet is.

This post is shared with Simple Lives Thursday.

This post may contain affiliate links. Thank you for supporting GNOWFGLINS with your purchases.

Do you love GNOWFGLINS?

Help us keep this site going by becoming a member! As a member, you get:

  • access to 8 online classes (and counting!)
  • 100s of videos and print tutorials
  • eBook discounts
  • monthly learning bonus
  • access to exclusive forums
  • and more!

Comments

  1. Alice Benham via Facebook says

    I tried this, but there must be something wrong with my crockpot, because after the first day my stock just tasted like burned bones. It was totally disgusting, and I had to throw it all out and start over with fresh bones on the stove. :(

  2. Alice Benham via Facebook says

    Nope, that’s the only one I have. It’s ok, though, because I usually have one day a week that I’m home and can make stock.

  3. Mary B Lapp :) says

    I have on occasion bought a $4.99 Costco Rotisserie Chicken. It is almost embarrassing to admit it, because I usually go for organic pastured chickens. But this $4.99 chicken makes the most gelatinous amazing broth I have ever seen! I have a hard time getting my $20 organic chickens to make a gelatinous broth. Any ideas of why this might be? Thanks! :)

    • Mrs. Mom of 6 says

      The reason you get more “gelatinous” stock from a rotisserie, is because of the carageenan that they add to the chicken. I have yet to find a rotisserie without carageenan added. If you can’t get your organic chicken to make a good broth, its one of two things: 1. you didn’t add enough vinegar and let it sit for an hour before heating, or 2. the organic chicken is raised in a chicken coop, not outdoors, and just given organic feed… this makes the fat poor quality, and makes the cartilage poor quality too… so you don’t get a good gel (chickens raised like that are not getting enough protein, therefore they are deficient in good protein, fat and amino acids). Try finding pastured chicken, or adding more vinegar, or take up Wardee’s tip and add in plain, good quality gelatin.

  4. Marla says

    I generally make my stock while cooking my chicken.

    I put either a whole chicken or just legs (whatever I find on sale) in the crock, cover half way with water and add the vinegar. I let it simmer until the chicken is done then remove the chicken from the pot. I remove the meat and return the skin and bones to the pot to continue simmering.

    This results in a stock that gels BEAUTIFULLY!

    I like the idea of perpetual stock, but I was using some of my last batch while it was simmering and found it to be toooo fatty. You mention it being fatty in this post. Is it supposed to be? I usually put my finished batch in the fridge and once the fat solidifies at the top I scrape it off.

    Is this a good thing or bad thing?

    • says

      Animal fat, from high quality, naturally raised animals, is good for you. At the beginning of the batch of stock there’s a lot of fat present. What I do is add both stock and fat to dishes.

      Fat isn’t desirable if you’re canning stock or if there’s so much you don’t like to eat it. But barring that, it is very good for you and very good to get in your dishes!

      Another consideration is that fat goes rancid more quickly than other foods. So it is good to use up the fat in the stock sooner in the perpetual stock cycle rather than later.

    • Martha says

      This is what I do. I remove the chicken when it’s done, debone it, put everything that is not chicken back into the broth and simmer on very low for another 8-10 hours. Very rich. Where I live, I can get more organic chickens than beef bones from pastured animals. That’s the biggest rub for me.

  5. Alix D. Melin via Facebook says

    had the same thing happen for me Alice, I never thought it might be a temperature issue. Hmmm, will have to try again.

  6. Debbie Matthews via Facebook says

    This is helpful Mari. My idea was to move in with you and have you perpetually make stock for me. :)

  7. says

    Hello I am just wondering about the cost of keeping the crock pot running all the time. I also think that it seems that it would be very important to have the chickens be organic since we are getting concentrated nutrients from them. Am I correct in thinking that?

    I would like to do a cost calculation about how much money it costs per quart of broth to make it this way – can anyone help?

    • says

      Adrienne,

      Yes, you’re right — high quality, pastured chickens are best. I meant to add that to the post.

      On the cost calculation, you’d need to know a few things:

      –cost of running the crockpot for a certain length of time
      –amount of stock you can produce during that same length of time
      –cost of bones and other ingredients

      Then you could find out what the cost is per quart, per gallon, etc.

      • says

        Marian — The vinegar helps pull minerals out of the bones. I really do splash. Literally. But if you want to be more specific, a few tablespoons up to 1/4 cup.

  8. Brenda says

    Learning about perpetual stock was a really big deal for me! I had previously been under the impression that you could only make one batch of stock with a batch of bones, and at an expense of about $10.00+ for each batch of bones, I wasn’t making it very often. So, I believe that one fact about perpetual broth deserves emphasis and repetition: YOU CAN USE, AND REUSE, THE BONES UNTIL THEY CRUMBLE! (Or, until you don’t like the taste – IF you can’t remedy that by adding herbs, spices, onions, garlic, or something.) I’ve found that I don’t need to put so many bones in my pot to have good broth as I had previously believed.

    I use a 6 qt. oval roaster oven for my perpetual broth, and can do my browning or roasting right in the same vessel on the Roast setting (350 degrees), then turn it off, add water and vinegar and leave it for one hour. (It has a removable porcelain cookwell.) When I turn it back on, I set it on Cook (300 degrees) until it gets a good simmer going, then turn it down to Slow Cook (200-250 degrees). This method is so much easier for me, because I have a gas stove and had the most difficult time trying to get the flame set low enough without it going out on me. This roaster really helps me to always have broth!

    A FEW WORDS ABOUT FLAVOR: 1) IMO, the flavor and color can be favorably improved if you take the extra time to brown or roast the bones first (about an hour), then make the broth as usual, adding the pan drippings to the broth pot. 2) I’ve learned that if you put carrots in it, especially if you put in too many, they make the broth sweet. That may or may not be a good thing, depending upon personal taste. IMO, sweet broth is awful, but it might help your children drink it. 3) If you don’t want bland broth, remember to add some vinegar each time you add water, which also helps pull the minerals out of the bones. 4) My favorite herb for broth is bay leaves, adding them every day or two.

    ONE QUESTION: How do you know if you still have gelatin in your broth when it’s always hot?

      • Brenda says

        Thanks for your kind words, Wardee, and for all the helpful information that you provide for us!!

        As if the above wasn’t long enough, perhaps I will add that my broth experience consists of using grass fed beef bones exclusively. I’d love to make chicken broth, but at $15.00+ for a 3 pound chicken, that just isn’t going to happen here. :-(

        • Kerligirl says

          If you calculate it out though, its not so bad. If I use that chicken in a recipe, I can get two meals from it. Then, I can get FIVE quarts of healthy organic chicken broth as well! I’d say that’s a pretty good deal if you look at how much you’re getting from that 15.00 chicken. You just have to get your mind off that initial price tag bc its way more than one chicken for one dinner. ;)

  9. Pei says

    We grew up having soup every meal so I really miss that. I’ve been wanting to start the GAP diet but
    have been unsuccessful because I haven’t been able to make broth regularly.

    I’ve made chicken broth with meat & bone. A chicken makes about 5 quarts of broth.
    It’s a long process cooking on stove top. I have used my 10 yrs old Rival crockpot to make broth over night
    & it boils hard at a low setting. Also I stop using my crockpot after reading risk of lead leaching into food.
    Perhaps I need to investigate to find a crockpot that is safe and try again?

    Question: Is it a good idea to break the big bones to get more minerals/nutrient out of the bones?

    I would like to make beef & fish stock also. Again that means spending time researching to find a good source for organic beef & fish head.

  10. says

    Hi Wardee! I make stock frequently, since I started GAPS last year in May. I now know that even when I’m completely off GAPS I’ll still be making it almost daily since it’s so nourishing and goes with so many meals we eat. I’ve always got some going or in the refrigerator or freezer.

    For many months, I made stock like you are describing and it worked fine, except that I found that after no more than 2 days, my chicken stock would start to taste off. I would often use up most of the broth and then add water again after several days, and sometimes I’d add a bit of apple cider vinegar again, more spices, and also some butter or ghee which I always add to my stock when I first put all the ingredients in.

    With beef, it would take longer for the off taste to develop, maybe 3-4 days. I got tired of it tasting off, so I’ve started taking it off the stove and just storing what I’ve got. I now think that may be because of two reasons: 1) I have really never skimmed off the fat from the initial heating. I always wanted to save it because I love the fat, and I just kept in in the stock because I use my stock for so many other things we eat – beans, rice, cooking meats and veggies, casseroles, etc., and 2) because for awhile I had the heat setting up too high (above medium) for the initial heating. Then many times it would get left there for 20-30 minutes because I’d be in the other room and would forget about it before I realized it was at a rolling boil, and for too long. But maybe it was something else that was happening that I’m not even aware of?

    In the house we’re currently renting, the stove is terrible and even on low it scalds broth or anything else if left for too long. We also don’t have a working timer. My husband decided that it was time to invest in something besides a crock pot since all of the ones we ever bought didn’t last very long and I was worried about lead or other toxins getting into our food. Enter the hot plate. Best kitchen investment I’ve ever made. It has two plates, and I can have stock going on it nearly continually without worry. I can also actually cook on it, just like the stove. And unlike a crock pot, it has many different heat settings – it goes from 1 all the way up to 12. I was always annoyed how my crock pots never had anything besides high and low, and wished I had more control over the temperature.

    The other thing I have always had trouble with is getting my stock to gel. I have done everything I’ve always read to get it to gel – with chicken I always add gelatin, use chicken feet with the carcass when I have it, etc. When I store my stock in the refrigerator, I always get the layer of fat on top, but it never gels. Do you have any idea what I could be doing wrong? Sheesh, I just realized this comment, which I intended to be fairly short, has now turned into a small novella. :)

    • says

      Raine — I don’t care how long, I love your comments!

      I think the off-taste you experienced before has everything to do with the fat staying in there too long and the crockpot running too hot.

      In any case, how cool about your hot plate.

      It is my experience (often) that when cooking the chicken, the drippings gel quite well and the stock less so. So if you’re cooking the chicken at a totally separate stage, try not using all the drippings in a dish (I know, it is hard!) and putting them in the stock pot too to share the gelatin love. :)

  11. says

    Thanks Wardee! :) Yes, I guess I have not been using enough of the drippings since we usually end up eating most of them when we cook the whole chicken. I always forget about that. Thanks for the reminder! :)

  12. Allie says

    Great post! I’ve been doing this as well but only every couple weeks. I freeze as much stock (& soup) as I can to use during the weeks I don’t make stock. I like to use my crockpot for dinner too, so I don’t want it constantly occupied. :)

    I have had a problem with stickiness in my crockpot though. When I go to wash the bowl after I’ve been simmer stock (on warm, even low makes it boil) for several days, it’s super sticky & gross & will NOT come clean unless I soak it for hours & scrub for hours. Makes me sad & consider going back to my old stock pot on the stove. Any tips??

  13. Carol G. says

    Hi.Wardeh and all,
    If I am not making a perpetual broth and just making a batch once every week or two then about how long do I leave it simmering? How long is too long in affecting the nutritional value and flavor?

    I do not want to leave cheaper appliances like crock pots (even the best) plugged in while I am not home as it makes me nervous about the potential of their staring a fire in my home as I leave my elderly mother who does not more very fast and pet in the home alone. Also, any suggestions for brands and models of crock pots that you have found tried and true would be most welcome.

    I figure I can save the bones in the freezer and use them again with any new bones I accumulate between batches so not to waste them with just making only one batch of bone broth. Do you see any problems with doing this? I cook for only three of us so I plan to freeze some with each batch I make so as I constantly use it I will be replenishing my stock in the freezer with each batch. I figure for only the three of us that should keep us with a constant supply of stock to have at least one cup a day as suggested.

    Thanks in advance for any info and suggestions!
    Carol G

  14. Ashley Whiteman says

    I’m just wondering about the onions and garlic I put in my beef stock, should I strain those out after 24 hours or are they fine in there for a few days/for as long as I keep using the same bones? Also, the meat on the bones, do I take the meat off after a day or leave it in for as long as I keep that batch going? I have a batch going right now and LOVE the idea of being able to pull what I need when I need it. I’m thinking I’ll freeze a quart every day or so to have on hand for when I need to use my slow cooker for something else. Its so much easier to take a quart here and a quart there rather then storing all of it at once. Thanks for all the information. ;-)

    • says

      Laura — I wouldn’t use onions and garlic in perpetual stock. They get very sweet, and at least I don’t like it. Yes, with the meat — cook till done, take the meat off, and return the bones to the pot. I hope this helps you out!

  15. Robert Parent says

    I remember, from my childhood, my great-aunt would always have a stock pot on the stove. Soup was served with every dinner and supper(they were from the old country where dinner was at lunchtime, but the biggest meal of the day, and supper was at dinnertime, but more like a lunch). I dont know how she started the stock, but most left-overs went into that pot. And the soup was always great. I think she threw it all out and started over every couple of weeks, but I really cant be sure.
    It’s a shame that that type of info gets lost as technology removes us from having to know it.
    I enjoyed the article, and I will try to keep a perpetual beef stock on hand …. just because I love a hot cup of broth in the winter months.
    Thanks

  16. andrea says

    Hello,
    I have a question for you. We butchered our own beef this January. I have two large nesco roasters going with bone broth. I am getting ready to change out the food scraps and continue on. There is still meat on the bones that is loose. Should I remove that from the continuing new batch of broth? Will it begin to spoil in any way? I would like to move forward indefinitely with the bone broth and leech as much out of my grass fed animal as possible. Bone broth is bone broth and not meat scrap broth right? Help me about the meat please? Thanks.

  17. Trudy says

    Every time I’ve made stock, either on the stove or the crock pot, it always bland and tastless regardless of whether its chicken, beef or pork. I follow all your instructions… what could I be doing wrong?

  18. Kim says

    I’ve been doing perpetual broth in a crock pot continuously for two or three years. Every morning, we dip out broth for everyone in the family. Then we change out the bones if needed, add more water, let it simmer again….. The first batch with new bones definitely has the best flavor and the best gelatin. But the subsequent batches just need some fat added in, and they end up tasting fine. The secrets to delicious broth are salt and fat. I use the same bones for three to five days, usually beef bones, chicken bones, or chicken feet. I never roast the bones or add vegetables, because I need the entire process to be simple and easy. Usually one of my sons (ages 6 to 12) does the whole chore by himself each morning. If we’re going to make soup, we skip the morning doses and save it all for the soup.

  19. Debby says

    What is the health benefit of drinking broth everyday? This is my first time to this website and I am finding it extremely interesting and would like to try this broth daily. Also, should I use Bragg’s apple cider vinegar or regular apple cider vinegar that just adds apple cider to distilled vinegar?

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Cold and flu season is well underway and since last week I have been running a series on immune building remedies like Elderberry Syrup, Garlic-Ginger Lemonade and now medicinal mushroom infused broth. I am assuming by writing this post that my readers are already well-versed in the art of making traditional bone broth as I have not written a how-to post of my own on that subject yet. Shame on me!!! If you do not already know how to make bone broth, there are many wonderful resources out there such as this post by Nourished Kitchen and this one by GNOWGFLINS. [...]

  2. […] Put the bones right back in the crockpot, with or without the dripppings, and add water and a splash of vinegar, then cover and turn on low for 12 to 24 hours. You can also add onions, garlic, and herbs. Here’s more info: Perpetual Stock or Broth in the Crockpot. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.