Homemade Bourbon Vanilla Extract

This post may contain affiliate links. Thank you for supporting GNOWFGLINS with your purchases.

Homemade Bourbon Vanilla Extract | One of the best and most simple things I've ever done is make my own vanilla extract. And bourbon vanilla, at that. Our homemade ice cream is 500 times better for it, plus everything else we make! | GNOWFGLINS.com

The two winners of the Family Camping Handbook are… Kristi and Kelli. Congratulations! I’ll email you both so you can connect with Katie @ Kitchen Stewardship, the handbook author.

One of the best and most simple things I’ve ever done is make my own vanilla extract. And bourbon vanilla, at that. I used to buy it at Trader Joe’s and really liked what it did for our ice cream, so that’s the kind I wanted to make.

Using homemade vanilla extract, our raw Jersey ice cream (and many other dishes) are out of this world. Like 500 times better. Perhaps that is an exaggeration. But the point is, homemade vanilla offers much more flavor. Here’s an example of what it can do.

I had some frozen Jersey cream (a bit freezer burned), back in May, I think. I made ice cream, using vanilla extract from Trader Joe’s. Nobody liked it, no doubt because of the freezer burn.

What’s wrong with the ice cream, Mom?

I had more frozen cream (a bit freezer burned). I made ice cream in late July, using my bourbon vanilla extract. The ice cream was amazing.

Mom, what did you do to the ice cream? Its soooooo good. Did you get fresh cream?

See what I mean? The awesome, homemade bourbon vanilla was so good, it masked mild freezer burn.

Here’s how to make it. It couldn’t be simpler. I used this recipe to guide me in making up 1/2 gallon.

Homemade Bourbon Vanilla Extract | One of the best and most simple things I've ever done is make my own vanilla extract. And bourbon vanilla, at that. Our homemade ice cream is 500 times better for it, plus everything else we make! | GNOWFGLINS.com

Homemade Bourbon Vanilla Extract

Split the vanilla beans in half, lengthwise. Scrape out the seeds. Put the seeds and beans in a clean half gallon jar and pour in the 1/2 gallon of bourbon. Cover the jar, then shake it gently. Put the jar in a dark cupboard. Shake it up every few days.

Start using it after a few weeks, though after 8 weeks it will be good and dark. Perfect. Use anywhere you would use normal vanilla extract. Below, I’m adding it to sourdough chocolate cake in this week’s new video for the Sourdough eCourse. Mmm.. See how dark it is? That vanilla is about 9 weeks old.

Continue adding vanilla beans and bourbon for an endless supply of vanilla — four vanilla beans for every cup of bourbon. This would make wonderful gifts, wouldn’t it — small, pretty glass jars for all your lovely people?

Have you made homemade vanilla extract? What did you think?

This post may contain affiliate links. Thank you for supporting GNOWFGLINS with your purchases.

Learn to cook the GNOWFGLINS way in less than an hour a week!

Provide your family with healthy, delicious, nourishing meals! As a member, you get:

  • 100s of videos in bite-size pieces
  • Weekly meal plans for you and your family
  • Access to 8 online traditional cooking classes
  • Exclusive recipes
  • and more!

Comments

  1. Robin says

    Hi Wardee! Just wanted to add that Ina Garten (the “Barefoot Contessa”), who also makes her own vanilla, doesn’t scrape her beans first-she leaves them whole to marinate, and once the vanilla is ready, she then can scrape out the beans as desired and use them for baking, etc., so they serve double duty (I bet the beans would be awesome in ice cream!). She also does say that she has had her bottle sitting in her pantry for almost 20 years!! I just think that is so awesome….:-)

  2. Erin says

    Hi Wardee,
    Thanks for the recipe!!!
    Do you use the oz or 4oz. size of vanilla beans from Mountain Rose Herbs?
    Erin

    • says

      Erin, I bought an 8 ounce package, with more than 64 vanilla beans. That’s enough to make 2 1/2-gallons of vanilla. So I think a 4 ounce size would work for you.

  3. Carol Oliver says

    Thanks for sharing. I’m excited to try this. After watching you use your vanilla in the sourdough chocolate cake ecourse it had me wanting to try it. Now I’ll be able to try it. Wardee you are a blessing.

  4. says

    Wardee, I’m so glad you posted this! I was telling DH about this and he asked what type of bourbon? He wondered if Jack Daniels would be ok. What type/ brand did you use? I was just thinking some cheap stuff, but if it makes a difference then I’ll get something better.

  5. says

    Tara — I bought one of the cheapest. Really, this could probably use some research. I looked at the ingredients for the most expensive to the cheapest and I think they were all the same. So, I bought the cheapest. There might be more to it — if you find anything out, let me know!

  6. says

    This is such a fantastic idea. It would be great for inexpensive Xmas presents. I <3 MRH and they have a bunch of small pretty bottles that would be wonderful for this.

  7. Kelli says

    Wardee,

    I knew I was going to win! I have never won a blog give-away, but we are going camping this week, and I just knew. Thank you and thank you Katie! I am very new to camping, but my husband and my children absolutely love camping, so there is a lot for me to learn. And they eat out of cans and boxes the whole time, so maybe I can sneak in some real food slowly but surely. I just wish I had spelled my name correctly, so that when it was mentioned in your blog it would be right!

    I would like to try making vanilla. I am going to put it on my list of things to do.

  8. Miriam Snyder says

    I have been trying this for a number of months with vodka, since it is nearly flavorless, but I haven’t got it to taste good yet. Now I see I probably need more beans to liquid volume. And maybe the bourbon adds better flavor too. I’m excited to keep trying.

    • Catherine Shane Worley says

      I’ve used vodka as well as rum when making vanilla. The vodka has no flavor so flavor is reliant the beans. Rum, depending on brand has minimal flavor but is a little better than vodka. Any bourbon, depending on brand, makes it more of a maple syrup flavor. When ever I bake I usually use the one with rum but I’ve never seen any of my gifts re-gifted. :) you can also run the cheaper brands thru a water filtration system, brita, and improve the flavor of the alcohol.

    • says

      Jen — Definitely! The original guide I followed said to combine 1/2 cup of bourbon with 2 vanilla beans. I scaled up for the 1/2 gallon of bourbon I purchased. I do use alot of it — every two days I use 1/2 cup for water kefir cream soda.

  9. Toni says

    My sil, who is also a gnowfglins ecourse member…I haven’t figured out her username yet (that’s something I’ve been meaning to ask her) Anyway, she was just talking about this and thinking on using the vodka because it apparently can be made from grapes or potatoes or grain and she is looking for something totally gluten free. We were both wondering about bourbon and how it is made. If anyone has any more info on that please post! We’d be interested in it.

  10. says

    Well, Wikipedia says “The typical grain mixture for bourbon, known as the mash bill, is 70% corn with the remainder being wheat and/or rye, and malted barley. ”

    This does look really amazing. I’d love to try it soon.

  11. Kylie Thomas says

    I am interesting in the process of having an on-going supply. You say you just continue adding bourban and vanilla beans, do you ever at any stage remove the old ones?

  12. says

    Kylie — I don’t think you need to, but probably at some point they will take over. I haven’t gotten that far yet, but when I do, I’ll just scoop out the old ones.

  13. says

    Toni — That’s interesting about vodka v. bourbon. I’m glad to know that and I’m sure others who are gluten-free will appreciate that you posted it. Thanks!

  14. Jessie says

    I’ve done this w/ vanilla beans and vodka. The bourbon vanilla extract you buy is generally called “bourbon” because of the type of vanilla bean. You can use bourbon for the extract, but it’s not necessary.

    I bought my vanilla beans on ebay when I did this. You can sometimes find great deals. I also got “grade b” beans which are smaller – but are fine for this purpose.

    If you want to find bottles w/o paying a lot for shipping (to make small gifts) – try pharmacies or medical supply stores. You can sometimes get the dark bottles that get used for liquid medicines.

    One other tip I heard was to take the beans out when you are finished w/the extract and after they are dry – put them in a container of sugar. Let it sit for a while – and you will get vanilla sugar. Not sure I will do that as I don’t want to consume that much sugar – but it sounds like an interesting idea.

  15. says

    I’ve made my own vanilla extract with vodka, bourbon, rum and brandy. So far I like the bourbon best, but vodka is a nice, bland liquor to extract into. My least favorite was the rum. No matter what I used it in, I could taste the rum! Good for some applications, not for others.

  16. says

    I use at least twice as many beans — 1 per ounce of alcohol! In my last batch, I made it in 4 oz. dark brown glass jars and used 5 beans per jar. I read a lot about extract and I think what you’re making, all though wonderfully flavored, would be more of a “flavored liquer” and couldn’t legally be called extract if you were selling it. Take a look at this: http://www.vanillareview.com/make-vanilla-extract/

    • says

      Kate — A friend called my attention to the fact that my math was off in this recipe. I said 4 beans per cup, but then only called for 16 vanilla beans in the half gallon. A half gallon is 8 cups, and 8 x 4 is 32. Not the 16 I originally typed! Now that I updated it, the recipe calls for double the vanilla beans — 32 — which is more in line with what you said and probably now considered vanilla extract. :)

  17. says

    I picked up some Knob Creek yesterday and took about 8 vanilla beans and started my batch. I’m very excited to try this. I agree that it will make wonderful holiday gifts. Thank you, Wardee!

  18. elaine says

    Hi Wardee~ This looks fabulous! I’ve got my vanilla beans and bourbon all ready to go – but have a quick question … I ordered waaaay too many vanilla beans — how do you suggest I store them for future use? Thanks so much!

  19. says

    Elaine — I have my extra beans stored in a dark cupboard. I suppose the freezer would be best, if you have room. I do have room, so mine are going in the freezer now. :)

  20. says

    Wardee, this is amazing! I’ve been trying to figure out an inexpensive way to replace ours when it runs out, but haven’t been too impressed with homemade vodka based ones. Bourbon is a fantastic idea! Thank you so much for sharing this!
    .ambre.

  21. Kim says

    I am so excited to try this! I have my beans on order and am wondering what kind of Bourbon to use. Does anyone have a favorite brand?

    I am also wondering, with trying to use as many organic things as possible, what do you know about the purity or quality of the alcohol you are using?

    I am so blessed to benefit from all of your experiences! Thanks to everyone sharing!

  22. says

    I just started a batch of vanilla extract with vodka in May and it keeps getting yummier and yummier as the weeks go by!

    We have to be gluten free, but regardless of what kind of grain it is made from it is gluten free because it is distilled. Beer is brewed and not safe, but liquors are safe.

    I’ve been thinking about making it into Christmas gifts too. Nice gifts and money spent now and not in the month of December!

  23. Jill says

    I have heard that a vanilla bean will last a LONG time…that you can actually use it over and over again to make new extract. Someone told me this but I can’t remember who! Has anyone done any research on the longevity of the beans?

    Also…last year around the holidays I saw whole vanilla beans at Costco next to the spices. I’m regret not purchasing a bottle then but I will keep a lookout for them this year.

  24. Katie says

    I was looking at my grocery store yesterday for bourbon and vodka, I was thinking of making two different kinds and see how they turn out. Everything I found at the store said it was diluted and 42 proof. I really don’t know anything about liquor, but my husband got online and found a few blogs that said you have to use at least 75 to 80 proof. which means I would have to go to a liquor store ( not crazy about that idea ) has that been your experience Wardee? if you used a less proof for the grocery store and had a good experience then I would try it as well and save myself the headache and high price of a liquor store.
    Thanks again for all you do!

    • says

      Katie, I got mine from the liquor store and it was a high proof. I don’t have the bottle anymore to declare how high. Perhaps your husband will shop for you? :)

    • says

      Katie — I just made more vanilla yesterday after buying more bourbon. At the liquor store, all their bourbon was between 80 and 90 proof (40% to 45% alcohol).

      What did you decide to do?

  25. Carol Oliver says

    Wardee, what do you think? I bought some vanilla beans. I split them, cut them in half (to fit my jar) opened them up. Then I put the split beans into my jar of bourbon. I shook the bottle up and could see the vanilla lifting from the beans. Scraping the vanilla bean was such a mess. So I thought leaving the open pod in the bourbon would do the job? Especially shaking the jar as you suggested every few days. Carol

    • says

      Carol, I think that would be fine. Up there, someone else commented that she doesn’t scrape the seeds out and then the vanilla bean paste can be used later in dishes. It is a good idea, and I’m going to stop scraping mine now, too.

  26. says

    Hey, everyone! I’m adding a comment because *sheepishly* my math was off when I typed up this recipe. 1/2 gallon of bourbon actually needs 32 vanilla beans — or 4 per cup.

    So sorry! If you’ve got a half gallon brewing, just add 16 more vanilla beans (the original amount I mentioned was 16) to make it up to 32 vanilla beans.

  27. says

    I saw a comment about storing beans in the freezer… and this vanilla bean site says absolutely not in the freezer– store in a cool dry place. They also say that they can keep for a year this way.

    Q: How should I store my gourmet vanilla beans?

    A: Vanilla beans should be stored in a closed, but not air-tight, container in a cool, dry, relatively dark place. Do not store vanilla beans in the refrigerator or freezer! (The cold will dry them out and may promote a particular type of vanilla mold.) The important thing is that the temperature be relatively constant and that air circulate a bit (unless they are vacuum packed, in which case you can keep them that way until use). If you do store them in an air tight, sealed container, we recommend opening it every couple of weeks or so to let the air circulate a bit.

    from http://www.amadeusvanillabeans.com/faqs/

  28. Tara says

    Does this bourbon vanilla ever smell and taste more like vanilla and less like strong alcohol? I’ve used very strong (90%) bourbon and it still is just hard alcohol. Or will it be vanilla alcohol?

  29. says

    Great post, Wardee! Thanks! Too bad I’m just now finding it so close to the holidays. I guess that I’ll have some really great-tasting vanilla next year! I can’t wait to get started.

  30. Janet says

    Hi Wardee, I was just reading another blog (Cheeseslave) about making homemade vanilla extract and a few people said that the brand “Makers” bourbon was GMO free. I haven’t had a chance to see if they carry this brand in California yet (I know nothing about alcohol) but as soon as I get to town I am going to do some checking. Thank you soooo much for posting this information. You have been a real help in my Kitchen. I love your cooking classes!!!!

  31. Tim says

    I saw this post as I was researching this last night for our late-night vanilla making party.
    Part of the rules of bourbon whiskey is that it needs to be at least 80 proof.
    From culling different sites I determined that the longer it sits, the more vanilla-y it gets and, it get extra strong with a higher proof alcohol.
    Last night we filled a dozen woozy bottles with 2-3 split beans.
    We tried these alcohols:
    jamaican rum 80 proof
    Early Times 150th Anniversary bourbon 100 proof
    Early Times 354 bourbon 80 proof
    a cheap $5 vodka
    Old Crow Reserve bourbon 86 proof
    W.L. Weller Special 7 year bourbon 90 proof
    a rare old scotch whisky I had around (I’m a bourbon man)
    Buffalo Trace White Dog Mash #1 125 proof (this is what they use to make bourbon, but instead of putting it in the barrel for 4+ years to make bourbon, it’s bottled up, quite vile but it may make a great vanilla extract)

    Will report back in 3-4 months with the results.

    Easiest recipe I found was buy a fifth of bourbon, take out two shots worth, add 8-12 split vanilla beans, and let sit in the dark for 3+ months, but shake bottle weekly.
    The reason we went with smaller bottles was I had them on hand and had so many different bourbons in my bunker that i wanted to ind the best one.

  32. Cher says

    QUESTION: This is my FIRST TIME making vanilla. I have used Absolute vodka and put 8 vanilla beans per cup. (I started with 6 beans per cup. After 5 months it didn’t seem strong enough so I added 2 more beans per cup, 3 months ago.) It has been curing for a total of 8 months and is VERY strong. I tried it in baking and it had a very strong taste. Last month I started a 2nd batch and I was thinking of mixing 4oz from the 1st batch with 4oz from the 2nd batch to dilute it. I prefer not to use a sugar syrup if I can help it. Any feedback or thoughts on how to make my first batch of vanilla less potent would be greatly appreciated.

  33. Kim says

    Wardee, I’m confused as to how you keep a batch going continually. How often do you add new alcohol? And doesn’t that dilute it so that it needs to sit for a while longer before using it again? It seems that would make it hard to maintain a consistent vanilla flavor.

    Kim

    • says

      Kim — Actually that bothered me as well (the possible dilution) so what I ended up doing was purchasing another 1/2 gallon of bourbon and starting more aging. So one 1/2 gallon is always aging while I use up the one that’s ready to go.

  34. Megan says

    Wardee, I saw the commenter post above about the non GMO bourbon, and I just thought I would clarify that it is Maker’s Mark. :) It is really good bourbon, and my husband was quite skeptical about using it for cooking and baking. He feels that it deserves to be consumed in a glass! haha

    It’s probably so good because it is non GMO! :) I went ahead and bought some tonight to start my vanilla tomorrow!

  35. says

    I did find out that Jim Beam and Jack Daniels both use GMO corn. The interesting thing is that the bourbon that is exported by Jim Beam is NON GMO corn. They only use the GMO corn for USA sales. :(

  36. Susan Smith says

    I make & sell vanilla extract. Vanilla extract reaches maximum flavor in two years, I don’t sell before then. It does not get any more flavor after two years. It can be fed; after taking some of the extract out add more liquor & a few more beans. I use 200 beans per gallon making it two fold.

    144 beans per gallon for FDA rules, if sold.

    FDA standards require vanilla extract must contain 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon during extraction and 35 percent alcohol.

    The Federal Food and Drug Administration has specific regulations in the United States regarding commercial extract manufacturing, there are variables that create significant differences in extract flavor and quality. For instance, the FDA requires a minimum of 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans to a gallon of a minimum of 35% alcohol to 65% water mixture.
    There are no regulations on the quality of the beans, so beans can range from premium-quality to the driest cuts and splits containing only small amounts of natural vanillin. Although 35% is the standard alcohol requirement, premium vanilla extracts often contain a higher percentage of alcohol in order to extract more flavor from the beans. More alcohol is okay with the FDA; less than 35% is not.

    Double strength vanilla extract is made from 200 beans per gallon of alcohol, as opposed to the single strength vanilla extract, made from 100 beans per gallon (triple strength vanilla extract is made from 300 beans per gallon). It is a strength indicator, not a quality indicator. Thus, half (or a third, for 3x) of the amount is needed in the recipe. The product is used largely by culinary professionals who want to achieve specific results. For example, if making a white cake or frosting, the goal is to use as little extract by volume as possible, in order to preserve the pure white color. Using half as much vanilla extract enables this. Others use 2x and 3x vanilla to achieve a stronger vanilla taste. Twofold vanilla means that one only needs half the amount that the recipes calls for.

    • Ted says

      @susan smith,

      I am very curious about the laws and regulations on making and selling vanilla extract. I have been pondering doing this on a small local scale for some time now, but have found next to nothing for information on regulations for doing this.
      I would Love to have a conversation with you about this sometime.

      Ted
      sfbluesummers@gmail.com

  37. Meghan says

    I’m not sure is someone else already mentioned this, but it looks like Four Roses and Wild Turkey are two non GMO brands of bourbon.

  38. Jack Horowitz says

    FYI bourbon vanilla is name of the type of vanilla bean, not that bourbon was used to make the extract. Though I am sure a vanilla extract using bourbon as the solvent is very good.

  39. says

    Just a quick remark which I see Jack already mentioned… “Bourbon” is the common name of all vanilla beans grown in Madagascar. It has nothing to do with “bourbon” the type of whiskey. I generally use vodka but a smooth bourbon or rum makes a great tasting vanilla also! And currently I have several different varieties of beans aging, all in vodka.

  40. Patti says

    I made my first batch of vanilla last fall and gave some as gifts to my daughters, d-n-l, and great niece…it was the best vanilla I’ve ever used! I made mine with vodka, but will try the bourbon next time, but yes, there is no comparison to the added flavor it gives…to everything!!

    • Sarah says

      I make my own coffee creamer using fresh raw cream, but after a day in the fridge, the vanilla taste from vanilla extract gives way to straight alcohol taste! I don’t add the extract until after I remove the cream from the stove, and I have even tried waiting until it cools, and even tried adding it while cooking it. Does anyone have any suggestions? All this is with high quality store bought extract. I haven’t yet made my own extract. I am very sensitive to alcohol, so I need to solve this. I have also tried vanilla powder, but I am not happy with that either. Help! :(

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.